Thinking about Jim Spencer

Called to and sent from Idaho Falls: Jim Spencer

(written by Charles Barnes)

Jim Spencer pastored Shiloh Foursquare Church in Idaho Falls (and its predecessors Shiloh Chapel and Shiloh Christian Center) from 1980 to 1989.  He left Idaho Falls to devote his full time to the ministry he founded to win Mormons to Christ, “Through the Maze”.  Jim passed away last Sunday in Boise.

Jim was born in Basin, Wyoming in 1942.  After service in the Navy, he worked for an electronics firm in Southern California, and according to his book, Beyond Mormonism, An Elder’s Story, his life at this time was filled with women, gambling and booze.  Yet he knew he was searching for something more in life.  That search took him to Alaska, and then back to California.  Through the testimony of a close boyhood friend and numerous visits from LDS missionaries, Jim was persuaded to become a Mormon; he was baptized in Santa Ana in 1964.  Over the next ten years he served in numerous positions, including stake missionary, youth worker and, for five years, gospel doctrine class teacher.  In 1966, he married Margaretta Long in the Idaho Falls Temple.  In early 1969, the family moved from California to St. Anthony so that Jim could attend Ricks College for two years, where he majored in journalism.  After a year at Arizona State University, the family moved back to Idaho and Jim worked at the Rexburg Standard Journal.  Reflecting on this time in his life, he wrote:

“A nagging sense of emptiness haunted the nooks and crannies of my mind.  Something within me, in quiet moments, cried out that my life was shallow and unfulfilling.  What could be wrong?  What was missing?  For one thing, I was beginning to feel genuine disappointment in the Church.  I was becoming convinced that something basic was missing.  I had tried, God knew, to fit into the organization.  In fact, I had fit in so successfully that no one knew I was dissatisfied.

So Jim’s personal search continued.  He took his family on a trip to Illinois and Missouri to visit historic LDS sites, and on the trip had contact with various Mormon splinter groups who raised more questions in his mind.  He began an investigation of LDS Church history.  And he probed various people – the Presbyterian pastor in St. Anthony, a childhood friend who had become a Baptist, a man he thought was a Catholic priest – with his questions, and they all pointed him to a relationship with Jesus.   These conversations led up to what Jim would later refer to his experience on the “Sugar City Curve”, while commuting between Rexburg and St. Anthony.

I entered the curve a self-centered intellectual failure who, after ten years on a treadmill of religious performance, was about as far from knowing God as I had been when I joined the Mormon Church.  I was sick of myself. Sick of religion. Sick of life.  “God,” I said, “Where are You? Where am I going? What am I supposed to do?”

Well, Jim, came the response, let’s start at the beginning.  The problem is, you are doing things your own way.  You say you want to find Me. O.K., here’s how to do it. Turn your life over to Me.

I must be crazy, I thought, I’m having a two-way conversation in my head.  But Mike had said I needed to talk to God.  Fred said I needed a personal experience with Christ.  Maybe this was it.  Just in case it was, I wasn’t about to pass up the chance.

O.K. God, I said, You say I’m supposed to what?

Give Me your life.

Yeah, right. But what do You mean?

You don’t seem to be listening.

I am listening. I’m just not understanding. Do you mean do what those radio evangelists tell you – give your heart to Jesus?

That’s it.

But I don’t even know what that means.

It means that you give Me permission to do anything with you that I want.

What do you mean by anything?

Anything means anything.

I had no idea of the full implications of the talk I had with God that day.  It would take weeks for me to recognize the deep significance of those sixty seconds when I said yes to Him on the Sugar City Curve.  That afternoon I felt an irresistible desire to read the Bible.  So after supper I found a copy of a New Testament called Good News for Modern Man (I had no idea where I got it) and went down to the basement by myself.  What I read put the finishing touches on the contact begun earlier in the day.

This was 1974.  Pockets of revival were springing up in Idaho Falls and other places in the Eastern Idaho.  Through these Jim found fellowship and encouragement, and in Christ he found the answer to his deepest need.  It took two more years before his wife –  who at first was ready to send Jim packing and seek a divorce, but then started seeing the change in his life, experiencing love in Christian churches, reading materials Jim had around the house, and for whom a lot of people were praying –  responded to an evangelist’s invitation at the Community Church in St. Anthony.

While pastoring in Idaho Falls, Jim wrote his first book, Beyond Mormonism, An Elder’s Story.  He later wrote eight other books, as well as hundreds of newspaper and magazine articles.  After leaving Idaho Falls and founding Through the Maze Ministry, he traveled extensively, holding seminars in local churches, and seeing many Mormons come to Christ.  In 1996 he and Ed Decker presented a seminar on Mormonism in Idaho Falls that was sponsored by fifteen local churches.

If you have stories of how God used Jim during his years in Idaho Falls, please contact us or post them on the Jesus in Idaho Falls Facebook page.

Jim’s obituary (more than was published in the Post Register), and tributes from people whose lives he touched, can be found at!/Obituary.



  1. By his association with fellow ex-Mormon Ed Decker, Jim Spencer showed that his life was less about loving Christ and more about hating Mormonism. Your endorsement of the methods of Decker & Spencer shows that you, too, care less about honesty, integrity, and fairness, than about winning the war against supposedly evil Mormonism. God does not play a zero-some game with us. He will reward us all, even Decker and Spencer, for the everything good that we have done, and punish us all for everything evil we do, unless we repent of that evil. But his forgiveness is conditional upon our humbly accepting HIS judgement. He alone knows the hearts of men.

    I respectfully submit that your judgment of good and evil is greatly impaired by the fog of war.

  2. I knew Jim and his family well, as his daughter Erin was my best friend from 6th grade on. Erin led me to Christ on the swingset in their backyard. When removing the final things from my father’s house this summer I found the Good News Bible she gave me on that day. Erin and I attended private school at the Idaho Falls Christian Academy during its 1st 2 years and then high school together. After we left svhool we moved in together. I introduced Erin to her 1st husband Dave Hanson and was 7 months pregnabt when I was her Matron of Honor at theur wedding.

    Jim and Margarita were like second parents, and definitely my spiritual parents. Jim and the Fousquare Fellowship laid hands on me to receive the Baptism in the Holy Spirit a day I will never forget. Often after Church I enjoyed dinner with their family as well as intellectual and spiritual discussions I didn’t experience at home with my parents ( I was raised Catholic but my parents did not attend). Once I was in the hospital suffering from a severe asthma attack (which I’ve had since infancy). My mother said that the Holy Spirit spoke to her through me to call Jim to pray for me. I was unconscious and don’t remember anything except waking up to Jim and 3 other pastors in my room, including Revered Foster who was principal of the private school I attended. All were laying hands on me and rejoiced when I came to. Apparently I was not expected to make it, but their laying on of hands and prayer changed the situation. I was sent home a couple of days later.

    I know Jim and Margarita prayed for me regularly and certainly cared for my spiritual well-being. Their family means so much to me. I would have been lost as a new Christian without them. Most importantly I learned just how essential it was to have my own relationship to Christ. That it was important to ask big questions and talk about things with God and others. It hugely influenced the way I raised my own children. Their home was always filled with love, even though there were trials. My friendship with Erin is one I will always treasure and Jim and Margarita’s pastoral care and attention gave me a solid foundation I have benefitted from ever since.

    I knew the family well, in some of their most unguarded times. He was a real man with real successes as well as failings. But Jim’s love of Christ and compassion for those trapped in darkness was genuine and real. Jim had wrestled with the big questions we all face and was called to share his experience and bring others to know the truly deep and personal relationship that is possible with a living Christ. He was gifted with wisdom and prophecy.

    I know his passing is a huge blow to the family but rejoice that he is with our beloved Savior.

  3. have no idea how Tracy Hall came to this conclusion. I knew both Jim and Ed and they loved Mormons very much. This came out in all my conversations with them as I picked their minds concerning talking with LDS. Jim was a soft hearted man with great sense of humor who was deeply in love with Jesus. friend,Tom Adams

  4. God used Jim for His Body. Through Jim’s brokenness God used him to minister to others. Has to be out of this world awesome seeing our Lord and Savior face to face!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s